Determination of the crack formation causes in a welded joint of a pipeline made of dissimilar steels
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.54708/26587572_2026_812444Keywords:
Welded joint, defect, crack, mechanical tests, fractureAbstract
This article identifies the causes of crack formation in a welded joint of a pressure pipeline, which had been in operation for over 70 years and failed under normal operating conditions. The appearance of cracks was detected along a welded joint of the pipe sections. Microstructural investigations have shown that the pipeline sections were fabricated from Grade 4 ferrite-perlite with a content of 75% ferrite grains, which related to readily weldable materials, and Grade 5 steel with a content of 28% ferrite grains, which refers to limited weldable materials. The obtained ultimate tensile strength and yield strength values of the base metals of Grade 4 and Grade 5 steels correspond to strength classes K50 and K52. On the basis of conducted microstructural and fractographic investigations, it has been shown that welding of such materials negatively affects the welded joint quality. The critical defect contributing to crack formation was an extensive lack of fusion with a depth of ~3–4.5 mm located at the weld root. This defect, found in the heat-affected zone of the Grade 5 steel, acted as a stress concentrator, leading to cracks initiation and propagation, which caused the pipeline technical failure.References
Khan M., Dewan M.W., Sarkar Md.Z. Effects of welding technique filler metal and post-weld heat treatment on stainless steel and mild steel dissimilar welding joint // Journal of Manufacturing Processes. 64, 1307–1321 (2021).
Ryabov V.R., Rabkin D.M. Welding of dissimilar metals and alloys. Moscow: Mashinostroenie, 1984. P. 241. (In Russian) [Рябов В.Р., Рабкин Д.М. Сварка разнородных металлов и сплавов. М.: Машиностроение, 1984. 241 с.].
Dijmarescu M.C. et al. Experimental study towards heterogeneous welded joint, case study: welding joint of carbon steel S235JR + AR with stainless steel 316L // Applied Mechanics and Materials. 811, 9–13 (2015). DOI: 10.4028/www.scientific.net/AMM.811.9.
Kah P., Martikainen MS.J. Trends in joining dissimilar metals by welding // Applied Mechanics and Materials. 440, 269–76 (2013).
Bakhla M., Shukla Sh., Kumar B. Effect of electrode composition over performance of dissimilar stainlesssteel welds // Materials Today: Proceedings (2023). DOI: 10.1016/j.matpr.2023.08.164.
Mvola B., Kah P., Martikainen J., Suoranta R. Dissimilar high-strength steels: fusion welded joints, mismatches, and challenges // Reviews on Advanced Materials Science. 44, 146–59 (2016).
Giudice F.L., Missori S., Iannazzo D., Sili A. A review on fusion welding of dissimilar ferritic/austenitic steels: processing and wela zone metallurgy // Journal of Manufacturing and Materials Processing. 8, 96 (2024).
Шабалин, Е. А., Муратаев, Т. А., & Муратаев, Ф. И. (2021). Влияние количества интерметаллида CuAl2 на микротвердость сварного соединения. Materials. Technologies. Design, 3(2(4), 37–42. https://doi.org/10.54708/26587572_2021
Sharma C., Dwivedi D.K., Kumar P. Effect of post weld heat treatments on microstructure and mechanical properties of friction stir welded joints of Al-Zn-Mg alloy AA7039 // Materials and Design. 43, 134–143 (2013).
Khafizov A.R., Nazarova M.N., Tsenev A.N., Tsenev N.K. On the role of construction and metallurgical defects in the destruction of main pipelines. Science and technology of pipeline transportation of oil and petroleum products. 7(3), 24–31 (2017). (In Russian) [Хафизов А.Р., Назарова М.Н., Ценев А.Н., Ценев Н.К. О роли строительных и металлургических дефектов в разрушении магистральных трубопроводов // Наука и технологии трубопроводного транспорта нефти и нефтепродуктов. 7(3), 24–31 (2017)].
Skornyakov A.A., Zaynullina L.I., Gabdullin N.K., Kharisov R.A. Investigation of crack formation in welded joints of various grades of steels. Pipeline transport – 2025: Proceedings of the 20th International Scientific and Practical Conference. Ufa: UPPC “USPTU Publishing House”, Ufa State Petroleum Technical University, 527-528 (2025). (In Russian) [Скорняков А.А., Зайнуллина Л.И., Габдуллин Н.К., Харисов Р.А. Исследование трещинообразования в сварных соединениях различных марок сталей. Трубопроводный транспорт – 2025: Материалы XX Международной научно-практической конференции. Уфа: УНПЦ «Издательство УГНТУ», Уфимский государственный нефтяной технический университет, 527–528 (2025)].
Fetisova E.A., Lupachev A.G. Features of diffusion processes in welded joints made of dissimilar steels // Bulletin of the Belarusian-Russian University. 3(44), 79-87 (2014). (in Russian) [Фетисова А., Лупачев А.Г. Особенности диффузионных процессов в сварных соединениях из разнородных сталей // Вестник Белорусско-Российского университета. 3(44), 79–87 (2014)].
L.S. Livshits, A.N. Khakimov, Metal science of welding and heat treatment of welded joints. Moscow: Mashinostroenie, 1989. P. 336. (In Russian) [Лившиц Л.С., Хакимов А.Н. Металловедение сварки и термическая обработка сварных соединений. М.: Машиностроение, 1989. 336 с.].
Sirohi S., Pandey Ch., Goyal A. A comparative study of two nuclear steel grades welded joints // Archives of Metallurgy and Materials. 65, 583–593 (2020).
Islam Sh.Sh.U., Khan N.Z., Siddiquee A.N. Review of heat treatment of welded sheet metals during past 15 years. Second Edition. Comprehensive Materials Processing. Elsevier, 2024. P. 41–56.
Molokov K.А., Novikov V.V., Dabalez M. Evaluation of the Occurrence of Initial Failures from Stress Concentrators in Welded Joints and Structural Elements // Advanced Engineering Research. 23(1), 41–54 (2023). (In Russian) [Молоков К.А., Новиков В.В., Дабалез М. Оценка появления начальных разрушений от концентраторов напряжений в сварных соединениях и элементах конструкций // Advanced Engineering Research. 23(1), 41–54 (2023)]. DOI: 10.23947/2687-1653-2023-23-1-41-54.
